This book is about a 14 year old girl who goes on a diet and is transformed from being extremely overweight and insecure to a normal sized girl who becomes the school soccer star. You are never too young to think about going on a diet. As the book opens, maggie is called fatty and chubby by kids at school. The premise behind the book is to show how maggie gains confidence and develops a more positive selfimage after losing weight and achieving her goals. She decides to eat healthy and then she becomes a superstar soccer player and attractive to boys. It is complete with cartoon like pictures and will be readily accessible and easy to read by your preschoolelementary aged child. Just consider the case of maggie goes on a diet, a forthcoming book about an overweight 14yearold. Aloha publishing provided this description on their site. Nov 16, 2010 maggie goes on a diet, alternatively entitled no one likes fat kids, is about 14 year old maggie losing weight so she can be pretty, popular, and a star soccer player.
In maggie goes on a diet, the main character is a bullied, overweight girl who decides to lose weight, and critics are worried its giving young readers the wrong idea about dieting. Aug 23, 2011 apparently, diet is one of the most incendiary fourletter words in the english language. Inspire a love of reading with prime book box for kids discover delightful childrens books with prime book box, a subscription that delivers new books every 1. Maggie goes on a diet the sensible way in childrens book. The book depicts a teenaged girl who is bullied for her size and then goes on a diet and becomes thin and popular. Paul kramer, author of the upcoming maggie goes on a diet, is an exnew yorker who decamped 15 years ago to hawaii, where his true passion in life dawned, according to aloha publishers, kramers selfpublishing outfit. Through time, exercise and hard work, maggie becomes more and more confident and develops a positive self image. I am the author of the book, maggie goes on a diet hi rabbi, is it possible that you have judged this book by its cover and by hearsay and innuendo and not by what is actually written in the interior of the book, its heart. Paul kramer, author of the upcoming maggie goes on a diet, is an exnew yorker who decamped 15 years ago to hawaii, where his true passion in. This image from maggie shows her eating to feel better after a dismal soccer game, below.
Okay so by checking its label i can say its okay to take it once in a week as a reward for your effort taken. Maggie goes on a diet author paul kramer defends controversial. Maggie goes on a diet, a new book by childrens author paul michael kramer, is drawing fire from those who believe it inappropriately focuses children on their weight and, by doing so, could lead. Maggie goes on a diet is a new book with a targeted reading level of ages 48 years old and coming out in october of this year by author paul m. The work, called maggie goes on a diet, is written in verse and aimed at those as young as six. Transcript for childrens book maggie goes on a diet causes stir. Kramer maggie goes on a diet hasnt been released yet, but the book about a 14yearold who goes on a diet.
Aug 23, 2011 author paul kramer defended his controversial childrens book maggie goes on a diet by saying a book about a dieting teenage girl helps kids make healthy choices. Author paul kramer finds himself in the center of a firestorm over his book maggie goes on a diet. The story follows maggie, an overweight 14 year old girl who goes on a diet, loses weight, and becomes a soccer star as a result. However, formatting rules can vary widely between applications and fields of interest or study.
The premise of maggie goes on a diet is basically that a young girl, maggie, age 14, looks in the mirror and decides that she does not like what she sees in the mirror. Maggie goes on a dietthe consequence the truth about. Doctor says parents should lose their obese kids dr. The book by paul kramer tells the story of a 14yearold. I shouldnt even be telling you about the book, because it appalls me to think of it getting in the hands of a parent or sigh a child. On a weight loss journey, how harmful will maggi be to my. Dominant notions of dieting in our culture are reified in this childrens book. Maggie goes on a diet raises storm of protests among experts. She is fat, she wants to be a better baseball and soccer player, goes on a diet, her team wins the soccer tournament. Maggie goes on a diet tells the story of a 14yearold who goes on a diet and is transformed from being extremely overweight and insecure to a normal sized girl who becomes the school soccer star according to the blurb, and gauges the reading level at 48 years old. Book about overweight child maggie goes on a diet draws ire. Jun 04, 20 dominant notions of dieting in our culture are reified in this childrens book. Maggie goes on a diet author was amazed by backlash.
Paul kramer, author of the upcoming maggie goes on a diet, is an exnew yorker who decamped 15 years ago to hawaii, where his true passion in life dawned, according to aloha publishers, kramer s. Kramer tells a tale of poor little 14 yearold, chubby maggie in this. Maybe kramer plans to write a sequel called maggie goes on another diet that features an emaciated 17yearold maggie out on a date, excusing herself to go into the restroom and jam a finger down her throat to vomit up her salad. Maggie after dieting so, by now, im sure youve become aware of a rather awful book aimed at children called maggie goes on a diet. Diet book for kids blasted for giving dangerous advice. Maggie goes on a diet author defends controversial teen. I guess technically the maradonia series was written for children, although with all the bloody violence and rape scenes thats an easy point to forget. Because remember kids, changing yourself to please people who ignore and make fun of you is a much better reason then your health or your own self esteem.
I get what the author was trying to say with this book but the execution is bad. But you have to know why its best to avoid it and be self disciplined. Pages in category 2011 childrens books the following 67 pages are in this category, out of 67 total. Maggie goes on a diet is a childrens book by paul kramer about weight management in childhood aimed towards children aged 612.
While the protaganist is 14, the book s target audience is actually girls as young as 6. Last night it was condemned by parents and experts for sending a dangerous message to vulnerable youngsters and encouraging eating disorders. Maggie goes on a diet is a story about an overweight young girl that decides to go on a diet and successfully loses the needed weight. No one was telling you to go on a diet, the book was showing you how life can be for a kid. Childrens book maggie goes on a diet sparks outrage. A picture book for children in which a pudgy 14yearold girl gets thin enough eventually to become her schools soccer star has come under attack. Published in 2011, maggie goes on a diet tells the story of an overweight 14yearold who, well, goes on a diet, starts exercising, and eventually becomes her schools star soccer player. Sep 06, 2011 by sarah case teaching kids to selfhate, give your child neuroses, and body fascism are just a few of the tags already linked to paul kramers childrens book, maggie goes on a diet, scheduled to hit the shelves in october. Maggie goes on a diet hasnt been released yet, but the book about a 14yearold who goes on a diet is available for preorder and parents arent. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. Its an open wound sort of topic for me with my sensitivity about this subject but mostly i am bothered by the probability of the damage that will be caused by the message in maggie goes on a diet. Maggie goes on a diet is not due to be released until october, but the childrens book about dieting is already sparking a controversy.
The book is supposed to teach children the importance of eating in. Aug 27, 20 maggie goes on a diet kramer 2011 okay, this one is horrible. Maggie goes on a diet inspires michelle goes on a diet. The childrens book maggie goes on a diet hasnt even been released yet, but its already been deemed problematic by many, and rightly so. Maggie goes on a diet, a childrens book that doesnt go on sale for another two months, has sparked a flurry of outrage online from critics who say the tale promotes eating disorders and. Aug 25, 2011 maggie goes on a diet, by paul kramer, tells the tale of an insecure 14yearold who sheds excess weight through diet, hard work, and exercise. Aug 19, 2011 a controversial childrens book tells how a girl transforms her life and becomes a school hero by losing weight. Maggie contains good amount of protein and carbohydrates which. Maggie goes on a diet author paul kramer responds to uproar about his book. Author paul kramer defended his controversial childrens book maggie goes on a diet by saying a book about a dieting teenage girl helps kids make healthy choices. Maggie goes on a diet is a childrens book by paul kramer about weight management in childhood aimed towards children.
The work, called maggie goes on a diet, is written in verse and aimed at. This poem was inspired by maggie goes on a diet, a childrens book for ages 6 and up slated for publication in october 2011. It seems calculated to create body image anxieties for young girls, who are already absorbing toxic messages from the media and pop. Kramer and illustrated by mari kuwayama is a selfpublished picture book written in rhyme for elementary aged children, but dont let it anywhere near. This asyet unpublished, selfpublished book would go unnoticed except that people like me are frothing at the mouth and the modern equivalent blogging like. David ludwig argues state intervention may serve best interests. My poem was originally published on the health at every size blog the description of maggie goes on a diet on the author paul kramers website reads. Maggie goes on a diet by paul kramer, hardcover barnes. Aug 22, 2011 a picture book for children in which a pudgy 14yearold girl gets thin enough eventually to become her schools soccer star has come under attack.
Maggie goes on a diet, is a childrens book that will hit shelves this october. My 11 yearold daughter asked me to purchase this book for her. Does maggie goes on a diet childrens book about losing. Maggie goes on a diet book for girls as young as six. The book is titled, maggie goes on a diet and is aimed at young girls, age 6 12 years old. Aug 25, 2011 through time, exercise and hard work, maggie becomes more and more confident and develops a positive selfimage. Psychiatrist supports controversial diet book for kids fox news. Thats why when a friend forwarded me this book, maggie goes on a diet, by author paul kramer, i found myself on a fence of mixed emotions. I am the author of the book, maggie goes on a diet hi rabbi, is it possible that you have judged this book by its cover and by hearsay and innuendo and not by what is actually written in the interior of the book.
Ive decided to spork a childrens book, for reasons that escape me. Maggie goes on a diet does not look like a good book. Oct 18, 2011 the new cover of the book previously titled maggie goes on a diet. Dec 16, 2011 maggie likes to play soccer and baseball. Why not call the book maggie loses weight or maggie eats healthy. Maggie goes on a diet, alternatively entitled no one likes fat kids, is about 14 year old maggie losing weight so she can be pretty, popular, and a star soccer player. Aug 25, 2011 the book reads like a demented collaboration between donald trump and karl marx. According to worldcat, the book is held in 19 libraries as of may, 2015. News, opinion and commentary general interest book publishing social aspects child health children health aspects childrens books. The doctors and author paul kramer debate the book s message. Childrens book maggie goes on a diet causes stir video. Dieting, maggie goes on a diet by usa today magazine.
Overview this book is about a 14 year old girl who goes on a diet and is transformed from being extremely overweight and insecure to a normal sized girl who becomes the school soccer star. It is anti bullying, she said to her bullyers, dont you have anything better to do. Paul kramers childrens book, maggie goes on a diet, scheduled to hit. Click download or read online button to get maggie goes on a diet book now. I wouldnt judge a novel by its cover, but when its a childrens book, the cover picture is fair gameand this pitiful line drawing isnt going to pull in a single discerning reader. Author paul kramer defended his controversial childrens book maggie goes on a diet by saying a book about a. If youre looking for a kids book about obesity, ed kochs. Maggie goes on a diet has long been a quest of read. Sep 12, 2011 even in the context of a book about a fictional person, i realize that weight is a touchy subject for many people, but it needs to be discussed more openly. Just consider the case of maggie goes on a diet, a forthcoming book about an overweight 14.
Can you tell if these childrens books are real or fake. Does a new childrens book, maggie goes on a diet, do more harm than good in the fight against childhood obesity. Maggie goes on a diet author defends controversial teen dieting. Maggie has so much potential that has been hiding under her extra weight. Aug 25, 2011 the book is titled, maggie goes on a diet and is aimed at young girls, age 6 12 years old.
The book maggie goes on a diet tells the story of a 14yearold girl who goes on a diet and is transformed from being extremely overweight and insecure to a normal sized girl who becomes the school soccer star. Maggie goes on a diet download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. Gambrel maggie goes on a diet is described by and other retailers as an inspiring tale about a 14yearold who loses weight and becomes the school soccer star. My poem and the video, michelle goes on a diet that lasted 20 years, was inspired by a very controversial childrens book for ages 6 and up that was slated for publication in october 2011. Kids book about overweight girl stirs controversy the. A new book for children called maggie goes on a diet is generating controversy ahead of its release in october paul kramers book tells the story of a girl who makes healthier food choices and. Maggie goes on a diet, girls talk back spark movement. Sep 02, 2011 maggie goes on a diet is described by and other retailers as an inspiring tale about a 14yearold who loses weight and becomes the school soccer star. No discussion of other possible scenarios anorexia, low selfesteem when not successful. Critics are slamming a new childrens book for feeding young girls the wrong idea about weight loss. I only found this title recently and doing a quick search i found that it had gotten some negative publicity. Sep 07, 2011 we first learned of this book on ontd and could barely believe our eyes.
Author paul kramer defends his controversial childrens book, maggie goes on a diet, saying the book about a dieting teenage girl helps kids. New diet book for kids, maggie goes on a diet, causes a stir. This book is about a 14 year old girl who goes on a diet and is transformed from being extremely overweight and insecure to a normal sized girl who. This transcript has been automatically generated and may not be 100% accurate. Through time, exercise and hard work, maggie becomes more and more confident and develops a. Maggie then decides to do something about her weight problem and maggie goes on a diet. Aug 19, 2011 according to the books blurb, maggie goes on a diet, tells the story of 14yearold maggie, who goes on a diet and is transformed from being extremely overweight and insecure to a normal. Maggie goes on a diet kids book sparks debate cbc news. Last week, i wrote an article about the kramer book maggie goes on a diet. As a consultant on sizism and teacher reading the discussion threads was quite discouraging. However, here are a few points in the book that did not set well with me what age is the book geared for. I was amazed at the difference between the discussion threads and the reaction of my 6th grade students to the book.
1534 873 1523 410 1307 1150 680 1505 1310 1448 360 1343 1106 1299 1173 378 1250 26 656 896 371 848 1615 725 1586 1020 1436 185 878 1222 753 863 1372 1383 747 614